Rejects File

[sdfan]

Powers that Be;

How's about putting together a reject file that lasts a bit longer so that us non-daily netters can have a chance to see the ones rejected to help us learn the mistakes?

Could you not create a file that keeps only a FINITE number of shots, say 100, then as 101 is posted, 1 disappears?

Thank you for your consideration.

Brad

[matnic17]

I agree there is much to be learned from having others comment on your rejected photos. Since they do expire in three days one option is to find another place on the web to upload them, and link to that location.

Here are some of my rejected photos, if anyone would like to comment.

I thought this one would be accepted for sure.
http://www.mattucker.com/train/AA2B05.jpg
It was rejected for bad cropping. Possibly the train is not prominent enough in the photo. I had another version which I don't like as much but I thought maybe the screeners would.
http://www.mattucker.com/train/AA2B06.jpg
It was rejected too.

This one was rejected. "subject too far away"
http://www.mattucker.com/train/AA2B07.jpg
To me the subject was the John Deere freight more than the on-coming train.

Here are some other rejections of mine
http://www.mattucker.com/train/AA2B08.jpg
http://www.mattucker.com/train/AA2B01.jpg
http://www.mattucker.com/train/AA2B02.jpg
http://www.mattucker.com/train/AA2B03.jpg
http://www.mattucker.com/train/AA2B04.jpg

Thanks for looking
Matt

[cmherndon]

How's about putting together a reject file that lasts a bit longer so that us non-daily netters can have a chance to see the ones rejected to help us learn the mistakes?

Could you not create a file that keeps only a FINITE number of shots, say 100, then as 101 is posted, 1 disappears?

A finite number of shots probably wouldn't be feasible since there probably quite a few rejects every day. I'd say well over 100 rejected daily. Maybe a better solution to that would be to keep rejects for a little bit longer, say 5-7 days. Just my two cents worth.