Help with rejects

[Miketherailfan]

http://www.railpictures.net/viewreject.php?id=76631
http://www.railpictures.net/viewreject.php?id=76632
http://www.railpictures.net/viewreject.php?id=76167

[Joe]

Hmmmm,
1) Too dark
2) Bad Cropping/Angle
3) Too dark

I like the third one, it's neat with the stroke of sunlight. :)

[Miketherailfan]

2) Bad Cropping/Angle

I like the third one, it's neat with the stroke of sunlight. :)

Actually, the 2nd one doesn't have a bad angle, the trains have to climb a hill to get to that upper level :wink:. BTW, thanks for the comment on the 3rd.

[quiksmith10]

The 2nd one does kinda have a bad angle. It seems to be more of a roster shot. The train kinda gets lost due to the cropping. The like the third one too. Good work.

[cmherndon]

The first photo just looks dark, and the dark paint on the locomotive doesn't help matters much.

Looks like you're on the wrong side of the tracks for your second shot, and there's a little bit of foreground clutter.

I do like the third one though. The composition is different than what you see of 90% of train photos. Maybe you should try to appeal it?

[Lord Vader]

I'd appeal the third one.