Wanting more feedback

[Dave Brook]

The following reject came back three times. The first time was for bad cropping. A little editing later and it came back as underexposed. A little lightening and it came back for the same reason. The admin line was blank. I don't want to waste editors time, and I freely admit to submitting some pictures that in hindsight were crap. Others, I just wanted a second opinion on something that I thought was different. If those who judge the pictures could offer a bit more insight as to why the picture was rejected, I think it might prevent a lot of the frustration that comes out.


http://www.railpictures.net/viewreject.php?id=98699

Cheers,

Dave

P.S. Opinions welcome!!

[E.M. Bell]

The only thing I see is that it may be a tad soft, but not that bad. If I where you, I would appeal...

[Chris Wilson]

My eye's go right to the locomotives... Thats a nice shot!

[Dave Brook]

Thanks for the feedback. This the rejected appeal. The admin line was blank. That is , I think, where a lot of the frustration comes from. Not enough frustration, I might add, to stop me from cintinuing to submit pictures.

Cheers,

Dave

[SD70MAC]

I remember reading when you get a blank submission results email back that means that the screener sent the photo to another person for a second opinion.