View Single Post
Old 08-04-2006, 07:42 AM   #4
Bryan Jones
Senior Member
 
Bryan Jones's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Brooks,KY
Posts: 131
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by tomcatchamp
I'm just curious, does anyone have an idea why the Union Pacific gave up on the SD90MAC-H II locomotives ? I've seen several of them in the photo section that are being used by the KCS with the UP markings lined through or removed.

The same can be said for the GE AC6000's. Did the whole idea of attaining 6000 hp in a locomotive and maintaining it prove to be too much of an undertaking ?

I know that the Canadian Pacific has a large number of these SD90MAC-H II in service, just wondering why no American ClassI railroads are using them.

Thanks in advance for the responses.

Joe
there were reliability issues with the SD90MAC-H and due to the fact that they were on a 5 year lease to the UP (lease terms were changed due to the long delay in delivery of the units) they chose to purge the units once the lease expired. Most if not all of the problems with the 265H prime mover itself have been solved, but electrical gremlins have plagued these units. The SD90MAC-H (along with the AC6000CW) was rushed into production far too early as it hadn't been fully developed yet and the units suffered many problems as a result.
Besides reliability issues, the 6000hp units have turned out to be less versatile than lower HP units. In most cases 2 6000hp units are too much power for a train, but one unit is not enough. Then there is the situation where you have a train with a pair of 6000hp units and one of them dies, resulting in the train being underpowered and possibly tying up the whole railroad depending on the particular railroad line and tonnage.
As for adhesion, the 6000hp units tend to be slippery too due to the 1000hp per axle rating of the units. Originally the railroads have pictured these units as being great luggers hauling heavy trains and thats just not the case. These units are best suited to high speed service. In heavy haul service the extra horsepower just increases the train speed, not the amount of tonnage that can be hauled.

Bryan Jones
Brooks,KY
Bryan Jones is offline   Reply With Quote