Inconsitencies

Dear all,

I have just met a weird inconsistency so I am seeking your views about it.

Accepted (and successful): https://www.railpictures.net/photo/747721/
Rejected: https://www.railpictures.net/viewrej...69&key=6644099

Both pictures were shot at about the same hour on the same day at the same place.
Both share the same historical value as everything in these pictures is now gone: the engines, the cars behind them, and the right of way (track replaced by a road).
Both are rare documents of never seen before consists in the RPN database,

A bit more homogeneity and consistency among RPN screeners would do good.

Anyone can explain?

Thanks!
Jean-Marc

[Decapod401]

I have no explanation, but to be honest, I like the rejected image better than the accepted one!

Originally Posted by Decapod401

I have no explanation, but to be honest, I like the rejected image better than the accepted one!

The accepted one is even more exceptional. There were very few occasions when the 2 series Ae 3/6 and Ae 4/7 were both present in a consist.

[KevinM]

Originally Posted by Decapod401

I have no explanation, but to be honest, I like the rejected image better than the accepted one!

I think the equipment in the rejected image is more interesting as well. The image is also noticeably sharper than the accepted one. I wonder, were they submitted side-by-side....meaning screened by the same person?

No idea why they were treated differently.

[Micha01]

Hello Jean-Marc,
hope you resubmit the photo. It's rare stuff, especially as both photos show the different side view of locomotives with Buchli drivetrain.

br
Micha

Originally Posted by Micha01

Hello Jean-Marc,
hope you resubmit the photo. It's rare stuff, especially as both photos show the different side view of locomotives with Buchli drivetrain.

br
Micha

Thanks Micha
This is precisely what I thought: this is rare stuff of historic value. But the screeners thought otherwise.

I just found this: https://www.railpictures.net/photo/748810/.

It is a nice picture
It is rare historic stuff
It is backlit
It was accepted
It is American...

[Grewup on the CW]

Jean-Marc,
How close together did you submit both pics? Normally pics this similar, especially at first glance, get the "similar as previous" rejection. The accepted shot has a bit of blur on the front of the loco where as the rejected pic does not. The wrong pic got accepted in that respect. The rejected pic is RP worthy. Try again after this post is forgotten about or maybe submit it as a color pic....JMHO