"Too Much Noise/Grain"

[gakei]

Hi all,

Where can you find which area(s) in this rejected picture that have "Too Much Noise/Grain" ?

http://www.railpictures.net/viewreje...41&key=6635480

I must say there are plenty of photos in the database which have much more grain/noise than this one including many of my previous photos :P

Thanks.

[JimThias]

Strange. It looks acceptable to me.

[gakei]

For information, this photo has been rejected once earlier for "Too much Noise/Grain". I then reuploaded a revised one after processed by a noise reduction software. It is again rejected for "Too much Noise/Grain". I suppose the screener should not choose the wrong rejection reasons unintentionally for twice.

This photo is taken by Canon S120 which is quite a new model. Not a DSLR but the noise should be acceptable.

Thanks.

[bigbassloyd]

Originally Posted by JimThias

Strange. It looks acceptable to me.

I agree. I'm not seeing a noise issue.

Loyd L.

[JRMDC]

Appeal, and tell them no one in the forum saw noise.

[gakei]

Then anyone may find that if this photo has other potential problem(s) that the screener might not like it therefore he/she might have rejected it for other reason(s)?

Thanks.

[JimThias]

Originally Posted by JRMDC

Appeal, and tell them no one in the forum saw noise.

Yeah, and reference this image while he's at it.

http://www.railpictures.net/photo/505749

[gakei]

Appeal was made and it is no surprised that the appeal is again rejected. Experienced these many times so there is no disappointment. Not much improvement of the screening process and response throughout these years and it is also expected. Nevertheless thanks all for your previous comments.