Opinion on cropping this

[Will]

http://www.railpictures.net/viewreje...&key=717195597

Would a vertical crop like this work better perhaps?
http://railfan.homeunix.com/IMG_5460.jpg

[baldwin8]

The second one looks better to me.

[gbrozny]

I agree that the 2nd crop is better, however I do not think it will make it with the sky blown out like that.

[EMTRailfan]

I think you needed a sharper curve to get the train across the frame more. I like comp. of the rejection (minus the sky), just not enough train filling the frame.