View Single Post
Old 01-12-2011, 07:04 PM   #10
Senior Member
PLEzero's Avatar
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Pittsburgh,PA
Posts: 675

Originally Posted by NathanAirChime View Post
To Brad & whoever called this a fake ( i think we know who it was) obviousy knows less about photography than i thought. And why would they send you a private message rather than call it out themselves? Care to share that info with the rest of the finger pointing crowd? I have the RAW and am willing to prove that the photo is not a fake and im sure Engineer Tom K can also verify it was a lite flurry of snow activity... i can say that the person that sent the private message has probably done some fake PSing on RP and is on the verge of getting caught and trying to start trouble as usual. Anyone here that seriously thinks this is a fake... please send me a message with your name and address and i will send you a copy of the RAW file that can not be mannipulated in any way and then see if u call me out that a fake... the DRAMA lives on... the only FAKE is the person or persons that fall into the Drama tory of this story
Not really sure where you are going with that Tom. If you think I am accusing your photo of being a fake you are wrong. The point of this thread is to point out how ridiculous some are over calling out fake photos. Your photo looks very real to me and nothing looks unusual. I believe everyone that has responded so far agrees with me. You also posted another photo to facebook from this sequence that has very real looking snow in it.

As Mitch pointed out, I think it was in better taste to question a photo via private message than to start a thread bashing a photo with no real evidence. How the message ended up in my PM box is anyone's guess. I would think he would have just contacted you through the link on the page with your photo. Although you rarely post to the forums he somehow got us confused (we are from the same area). Did he end up sending you a message after he realized his mistake or did he decide against it after reading my response?
Brad Morocco
Candyland, PA
My Flickr Photos
My Photos
PLEzero is offline   Reply With Quote